Rejoinder to Jason Palmer and Julie Goodman’s Response Papers
First, I want to give a shout-out to Michael Schiffman who is responsible for suggesting my name to do this paper. There were times during the research and writing of the paper that I could not believe that a friend could do that to a friend. But there were other times that I was thankful that I had the opportunity to contribute to this most valuable discussion. So, thank you Michael and the Hashivenu Board for giving me this great honor.
The paper took me from the world of cutting-edge science through ancient worldviews and the baal taschit (do not commit waste) world of Jewcology to just thinking on the topic, and trying to arrange it in some logical order. In fact, I wrote the paper once and then scrapped the 47 pages and re-wrote it to tame this chaos monster that threatened to go outside the boundaries of the assignment. And I have been truly enriched. Had I had the benefit of Julie’s and Jason’s peer review during the process I think that it might have taken on a third rewrite, or at least a revision. Such is the nature of academia. We improve our work by “iron sharpening iron.” I am thankful that both Julie and Jason have provided plenty of that iron.