Between and Among Communities of Faith
It was Groucho Marx who said, “I wouldn’t want to be a part of any club that would have me as a member.” I feel like I can relate to this. For the Jewish people, identity and community are interconnected. The nature of being part of Kol Israel connects us to the wider Jewish community and backwards in time to the patriarchs and sages. For the body of Messiah, the relationship is parallel; a body is made up of individual parts and organs working together. But what happens when those communities are in tension with each other and the individual identity? The question of who I am cannot be answered apart from who I am in relationship to the broader community.
I grew up in Reform Judaism, which, looking back, gave me a strong sense of Jewish identity and some connectedness to community, if not a strong relationship to Hashem and Torah. While not fully embracing the dual Torah as other modes of Judaism did, Reform Judaism was an opportunity to participate in the broad cycle of Jewish life such as the Passover seder, to participate in the life-cycle events such as my Bar Mitzvah, and to embrace Tikkun Olam as well as the cultural Judaism of lox and whitefish and self-deprecating humor. This broader cultural identity was more strongly emphasized in my upbringing than was being part of a people descended from Israel who were to keep Torah. Sunday school gave me the opportunity to learn the Hebrew letters, to give tzedakah, and to solidify my identity as a Jew. Jewish identity only takes shape in the context of community. Connecting to the broader Jewish community wasn’t necessarily on my radar growing up, but this is reflected in the individualization of Reform Judaism. Nevertheless, I always felt this connection even if I wasn’t a particularly observant Jew. I didn’t keep Kosher or keep Shabbat, but these were not really challenged at shul; I didn’t have a strong desire or reason to observe the Torah, and it was never presented as covenantal. Ironically, this connected me with most of the local Reform community which was also not especially observant.