Paul Employing Leviticus: Same-Sex Intercourse Considered Amongst Torah Commandments
It is sometimes argued that because the New Testament writers set aside circumcision, food laws, Sabbath, biblical purity laws, and welcomed Gentiles, anything in the Old Testament ought to be set aside if unsuitable for the ekklesia.[1] Recently, this argument has been raised with regard to the prohibition of same-sex intercourse in Leviticus. A seminary professor writes:
We distinguish between a strictly religious taboo and an ethical principle, and we associate the divine imperative with the ethical. … The ethical and humane take precedence over tribal religious tradition, which in the New Testament is called ‘the tradition of the elders.’ Jesus’ words, ‘The Sabbath was made for humankind not humankind for the Sabbath,’ are a good example of this. According to this principle, therefore, the cultic taboos may be rejected, modified, or continued in their original form. This was the problem with which the New Testament church wrestled in the case of circumcision and the clean and unclean taboos. … The argument from Romans 1:16-17 would be more persuasive except for the fact that there is a crucial theological change in the polemical rules of engagement. For Paul, the ‘righteousness’ that separates followers of Christ from unbelievers is a faith righteousness (Rom 1:16-17), not that ‘of the law.’ ‘Holiness’ has been redefined as we noted above. We are not tied to the letter of the Levitical prohibitions. … Hence it is not in the spirit of Paul’s gospel to simply transfer the legal, blanket proscription of homosexual intercourse in the Levitical code to the New Testament.[2]